Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Week Eight: No Child Left Behind

An article from LA Times shared Arne Duncan's ideas for rewriting the No Child Left Behind Act. Duncan stressed that teacher evaluations need to be much more in depth and Standardized testing needs to be interpreted differently. Right now, our education system has so many educators that just do not live up to the expectations of the job and it is hard to replace them. Therefore, I agree with Duncan that we need a better system for evaluating our teachers and making sure all students get a valuable education. Duncan suggests that standardized tests should be used for teacher evaluation. I'm not sure I agree with his idea on how to evaluate teachers. This would require schools to administer tests every year and in every subject for high school. This would require many states to create several new tests which requires funding. Also, there is no guarantee that tests will reflect the teachers effectiveness accurately. Students do not always perform at their best on tests nor do these tests measure skills such as critical thinking, work ethic, etc, that the teacher may be teaching. I also agree with Duncan that rather than having a 100% proficiency goal, a yearly goal of increased proficiency would be more realistic but also more efficient in improving school systems. Schools would not be as likely to put off improving their academic rigor. But, I also think that these tests should not be a determining factor in whether or not a school stays open or closes. These scores as well as other factors should be used to determine how the school needs to be improved and something should be done to fix it not completely destroy it.

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Week Six: Equal Educational Opportunity

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/11/opinion/11douthat.html?ref=equaleducationalopportunities

We talked a bit in class about a free market school system. Our current school system does allow for students to enroll in private schools and provides vouchers for those in need but it ultimately is not a free market. A free market school system would allow students to enroll at the school of choice and would therefore create real competition in schools and schools will, therefore, improve. As enrollment in public schools decreased in certain areas, the amount of money spent per student actually increased. Therefore, schools felt no pressure to make changes to get those students back! -- rather they were "rewarded". 
However, if parents had the opportunity to choose where their child would receive their education, and the money went to the school of their choice, schools would actually feel pressure to create a good learning environment and provide students with what they need. This is a very extreme idea and will probably not happen in the near future. But it just goes to show that if schools feel pressure to make their schools what they should be, they will! Not only will this provide better schools but also help resolve the problem of achievement gaps and other educational problems. The US government needs to rethink how funds are distributed among schools and fast!