http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8601207.stm
I watched a video from BBC news on why Finland's education systems are attaining such high scores. The This is what the video shared. Some Finland schools have one teacher stay with the students for several years. the teacher said this is beneficial because she knows the students so well and they do not get a new teacher just as the teacher is getting to know them. some classrooms also have multiple teachers. This allows students who need extra help to get it and all students can have the chance to work with diversity. advanced students can help those who need help. The video also shared that PE is a big part of the education system. All students receive physical education. Even though students spend less time in school than in any other developed country, they seem to use the time more efficiently. The video also asked businesses what they were looking for in students. They said they were looking for students with skills in math science and computer skills and so far Finland is doing well. Also stressed was the role of family outside of school. The parents play an important role in keeping their children motivated and stressing the importance of education.
I disagree with the advantage of having one teacher for multiple years. I think it is important for students to experience different teachers. I value the diversity in teaching methods I had in high school because it prepared me for college. I did like the multiple teacher classroom. However, I think this would be mostly effective at elementary levels. The US, in my opinion, should value PE like Finland does. Physical fitness is not only important to each student's health but it would also help to better their educational performance.
Wednesday, May 4, 2011
Chinese Education
http://www.usatoday.com/money/world/2011-02-01-asia_education01_ST_N.htm
This article talks about how the Chinese have scored high on tests and how. But, it also discusses what the Chinese Education system lacks. The Chinese Education system is very disciplined and is able to produce high test scores, however, they are not producing creative and innovative thinkers that today's job market demands.
Some think the US needs to catch up to China in Math and Science if we want jobs for the future. However, many asian students are coming to the US to be educated. In the US, students are encouraged to ask questions and think creatively because Colleges look at more than test scores unlike China where the only determinant for college entry is a test. It is those students from Asia that want to think critically that come to the US to expand their education.
I agree with this article. So many are saying that we need to improve our test scores compared to other countries. However, I think there are more important aspects of schools that need improving first, and that will probably raise test scores themselves. The average test scores do not mean the US students are in trouble, it simply means we are learning more than how to succeed on a test.
This article talks about how the Chinese have scored high on tests and how. But, it also discusses what the Chinese Education system lacks. The Chinese Education system is very disciplined and is able to produce high test scores, however, they are not producing creative and innovative thinkers that today's job market demands.
Some think the US needs to catch up to China in Math and Science if we want jobs for the future. However, many asian students are coming to the US to be educated. In the US, students are encouraged to ask questions and think creatively because Colleges look at more than test scores unlike China where the only determinant for college entry is a test. It is those students from Asia that want to think critically that come to the US to expand their education.
I agree with this article. So many are saying that we need to improve our test scores compared to other countries. However, I think there are more important aspects of schools that need improving first, and that will probably raise test scores themselves. The average test scores do not mean the US students are in trouble, it simply means we are learning more than how to succeed on a test.
Wednesday, April 13, 2011
Week 11 Globalization
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/11/world/asia/11iht-educBriefs11.html?_r=1&ref=education
This article from the New York Times shares that while the US, Britain, and Germany are still at the forefront of scientific research, other countries are catching up. China, India, and Brazil in the past were not countries known for their contributions to the scientific community. In the past few years, however, they have made terrific gains. China, for example, is now second in the production of scientific research moving from 4 percent to 10 percent of the papers produced. While China has definitely made progress, the US is still by far in first with 21 percent.
The idea of other countries making these progressions in the science world seems to scare the United States. I feel that we should want other countries to have the opportunities to produce the research that the United States does. Successful research does not only benefit the country that made the discovery but the world as a whole. Therefore, the United States should focus on the important thing, research is getting done. Because another country steps up how much progress they make does not mean we are less successful. I feel that is a huge problem today. One countries success seems to mean failure for the rest.
I think this is one place where globalization would be a good thing. Sharing success in new discoveries. Especially since so many discoveries are made in a joint effort. Rather than worrying that we are falling behind, we need to take what another country has learned and build off of it, and vice versa. This same concept can be applied to the education system. If one country has been successful in improving their education system, we need to learn from their innovations and consider if they would be good for our own system.
This article from the New York Times shares that while the US, Britain, and Germany are still at the forefront of scientific research, other countries are catching up. China, India, and Brazil in the past were not countries known for their contributions to the scientific community. In the past few years, however, they have made terrific gains. China, for example, is now second in the production of scientific research moving from 4 percent to 10 percent of the papers produced. While China has definitely made progress, the US is still by far in first with 21 percent.
The idea of other countries making these progressions in the science world seems to scare the United States. I feel that we should want other countries to have the opportunities to produce the research that the United States does. Successful research does not only benefit the country that made the discovery but the world as a whole. Therefore, the United States should focus on the important thing, research is getting done. Because another country steps up how much progress they make does not mean we are less successful. I feel that is a huge problem today. One countries success seems to mean failure for the rest.
I think this is one place where globalization would be a good thing. Sharing success in new discoveries. Especially since so many discoveries are made in a joint effort. Rather than worrying that we are falling behind, we need to take what another country has learned and build off of it, and vice versa. This same concept can be applied to the education system. If one country has been successful in improving their education system, we need to learn from their innovations and consider if they would be good for our own system.
Wednesday, April 6, 2011
Week 10: International Tests and Their Impact on Education
http://www.google.com/reader/view/?hl=en&tab=wy#search/International%20testing%20/5
Just like there debates on how accurate state and national tests are, the same goes for international testing. Finland has scored exceptionally well on international tests making them a model for education around the world. China has also done well on the tests causing other countries to worry they will pass them on the tests.
However, there may be reasons these countries scores are so high compared to other countries. Finland has an education system that follows a curriculum that is well aligned with the PISA tests. When tested with other forms of national testing, Finland does not perform as high. As for China, only two cities were tested. The cities that were tested are known for having an exceptional education system. However, if the other schools in China were included in the testing, the scores would have differed due to the change in education quality.
This article also points out why America may not be among the top performing countries. The poverty rate among children in the US is high among other participating countries. Poverty has proven to be a hindering effect on educational achievement. However, when scores of students at the poverty level are compared with other students in poverty, the US proves successful. This shows that compared with other countries, we have narrowed the gap between students.
Wednesday, March 23, 2011
Week Eight: No Child Left Behind
An article from LA Times shared Arne Duncan's ideas for rewriting the No Child Left Behind Act. Duncan stressed that teacher evaluations need to be much more in depth and Standardized testing needs to be interpreted differently. Right now, our education system has so many educators that just do not live up to the expectations of the job and it is hard to replace them. Therefore, I agree with Duncan that we need a better system for evaluating our teachers and making sure all students get a valuable education. Duncan suggests that standardized tests should be used for teacher evaluation. I'm not sure I agree with his idea on how to evaluate teachers. This would require schools to administer tests every year and in every subject for high school. This would require many states to create several new tests which requires funding. Also, there is no guarantee that tests will reflect the teachers effectiveness accurately. Students do not always perform at their best on tests nor do these tests measure skills such as critical thinking, work ethic, etc, that the teacher may be teaching. I also agree with Duncan that rather than having a 100% proficiency goal, a yearly goal of increased proficiency would be more realistic but also more efficient in improving school systems. Schools would not be as likely to put off improving their academic rigor. But, I also think that these tests should not be a determining factor in whether or not a school stays open or closes. These scores as well as other factors should be used to determine how the school needs to be improved and something should be done to fix it not completely destroy it.
Wednesday, March 2, 2011
Week Six: Equal Educational Opportunity
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/11/opinion/11douthat.html?ref=equaleducationalopportunities
We talked a bit in class about a free market school system. Our current school system does allow for students to enroll in private schools and provides vouchers for those in need but it ultimately is not a free market. A free market school system would allow students to enroll at the school of choice and would therefore create real competition in schools and schools will, therefore, improve. As enrollment in public schools decreased in certain areas, the amount of money spent per student actually increased. Therefore, schools felt no pressure to make changes to get those students back! -- rather they were "rewarded".
However, if parents had the opportunity to choose where their child would receive their education, and the money went to the school of their choice, schools would actually feel pressure to create a good learning environment and provide students with what they need. This is a very extreme idea and will probably not happen in the near future. But it just goes to show that if schools feel pressure to make their schools what they should be, they will! Not only will this provide better schools but also help resolve the problem of achievement gaps and other educational problems. The US government needs to rethink how funds are distributed among schools and fast!
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Week Four: History of American Education!
http://www.google.com/reader/view/?hl=en&tab=wy#search/charter%20schools/2
For the outside reading, I read from the blog Bridging Differences.. an entry titled Closing Public Schools: A Truly Bad Idea. In New York City, the mayor has been on a spree of closing public schools due to low test scores. At the same time, however, he has allowed a large number of charter schools to open up. Charter schools, unlike public schools, have the ability to turn students down and can, therefore, achieve higher test scores.
Instead of fixing the problem within the schools, the mayor has chosen to simply lock the doors. A choice that takes little effort, reflection, or critical thinking. This is not a solution! closing a school does not hurt those students who are struggling.. the only way to help is to find out why they struggle and go in and fix it.
I do not feel that the mayor is doing his job here. Public schools are important to the American education system and should not be eliminated. I agree with Diane when she says that "If those who are in charge can't help struggling schools, shame on them". Every leader should want to improve the education system not just monitor it.
For the outside reading, I read from the blog Bridging Differences.. an entry titled Closing Public Schools: A Truly Bad Idea. In New York City, the mayor has been on a spree of closing public schools due to low test scores. At the same time, however, he has allowed a large number of charter schools to open up. Charter schools, unlike public schools, have the ability to turn students down and can, therefore, achieve higher test scores.
Instead of fixing the problem within the schools, the mayor has chosen to simply lock the doors. A choice that takes little effort, reflection, or critical thinking. This is not a solution! closing a school does not hurt those students who are struggling.. the only way to help is to find out why they struggle and go in and fix it.
I do not feel that the mayor is doing his job here. Public schools are important to the American education system and should not be eliminated. I agree with Diane when she says that "If those who are in charge can't help struggling schools, shame on them". Every leader should want to improve the education system not just monitor it.
Wednesday, February 9, 2011
Week Three: Critical Pedagogy!
For the outside reading I went to http://aeroeducation.org/ and watched the seminar given by Don "Four Arrows" Jacobs. The seminar was "What you Don't Teach is Killing Our Children.." There were several topics discussed in the seminar that related to critical pedagogy.
First, hegemony seemed to be a big part. Jacobs pointed out that music, although very important in many cultures, is the first thing that is being taken out of school curriculums. I feel music is not only an enjoyable subject for many students, but also a great way for students to learn about and experience cultures other than their own. Arizona passed a law that banned the teaching of lessons that had to do with just one culture or any lessons that could be interpreted as encouraging the overthrow of the American government. This law does no good for those students and can only harm them. How ignorance towards other cultures is positive is beyond me.
Also, Jacobs pointed out that a study showed K-8 education majors are at the top of the list for not wanting to have to think critically. Secondary education majors are right behind them. If teachers are entering the field because they think they will not have to think critically, there is no way any aspect of critical pedagogy can be practiced. I feel that a teacher who is able to adapt their lesson plans and learn with the students is one who is also a constant critical thinkiner.
First, hegemony seemed to be a big part. Jacobs pointed out that music, although very important in many cultures, is the first thing that is being taken out of school curriculums. I feel music is not only an enjoyable subject for many students, but also a great way for students to learn about and experience cultures other than their own. Arizona passed a law that banned the teaching of lessons that had to do with just one culture or any lessons that could be interpreted as encouraging the overthrow of the American government. This law does no good for those students and can only harm them. How ignorance towards other cultures is positive is beyond me.
Also, Jacobs pointed out that a study showed K-8 education majors are at the top of the list for not wanting to have to think critically. Secondary education majors are right behind them. If teachers are entering the field because they think they will not have to think critically, there is no way any aspect of critical pedagogy can be practiced. I feel that a teacher who is able to adapt their lesson plans and learn with the students is one who is also a constant critical thinkiner.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)